初次培训后ASPECT评分一致性和准确性的研究

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5765.2017.12.007

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

目的评价初次培训后Alberta卒中项目早期计算机断层扫描（computed tomography，CT）评分（Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score，ASPECTS）的一致性和准确性，为其临床应用及推广奠定基础。方法收集30例起病6 h内脑梗死患者CT及简要临床资料。对不同科室28人（其中影像科21人，神经内科7人）、不同资历（工龄≥10年18人、＜10年10人）进行初次培训后，对所有患者入院首次非增强 CT（noncontrast CT，NCCT）进行ASPECTS。将ASPECTS作为分类变量，采用Fleiss' Kappa值评估ASPECTS 系统的一致性，采用正确率评估ASPECTS系统的准确性。结果整体ASPECTS的Kappa值为0.102，95%可信区间（confidence interval，CI）为（0.094，0.110）；影像科、神经内科评分者的Kappa值及95%CI分别为0.116（0.105，0.128）、0.067（0.034，0.099）。正确率：28位评分者整体840例次ASPECTS具体分值的正确率为15.595%；二分法（ASPECTS≥6或＜6）为 73.571%，差异有统计学意义（P＜0.05）；不同科室的二分法正确率：影像科74.92%，神经内科 69.523%，差异无统计学意义。二分法不同资历正确率：工龄≥10年74.814%，工龄＜10年61.665%，差异无统计学意义。结论初次培训后ASPECTS的一致性与准确性均较低，提示多次、严格ASPECTS培训极为必须和重要；二分法（ASPECTS≥6或ASPECTS＜6）有较好的临床应用前景。

文章导读： 本研究以磁共振弥散加权成像为主要依据确定Alberta卒中项目早期计算机断层扫描评分（Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score，ASPECTS）标准结果，以此评价真实世界ASPECTS的准确性和一致性，揭示其中存在的问题，为其临床应用和推广提出改良思考。

关键词: 缺血性卒中; Alberta卒中项目早期CT评分; 正确率; 一致性

Abstract:

Objective To evaluate the consistency and accuracy of Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score (ASPECTS) after the initial training, so as to lay a foundation for the clinical applications and propagations. Methods Brief clinical materials of 30 patients with suspected acute ischemic stroke were collected within 6 hours after onset. A total of 28 employees (21 from imaging department and 7 from neurology department) with different professional working-year (18 people with 10 years or more as senior employees, and the other 10 with less than 10 years as junior employees) were selected to make ASPECTS for all the patients’ first admission noncontrast CT (NCCT) after their initial training. The ASPECTS was taken as a categorical variable. Its consistency was evaluated by Fleiss Kappa statistics, and its accuracy was assessed by the correct rate. Results The overall ASPECTS Kappa value was 0.102, and 95% confidence interval was (0.094, 0.110); the raters Kappa value and 95% confidence interval from imaging department was 0.116 (0.105, 0.128); the raters Kappa value and 95% confidence interval from neurology department was 0.067 (0.034, 0.099). Accuracy: the correct rate of 28 raters was 15.595% after 840 case-time ASPECTS in overall. With the method of dichotomy (ASPECTS ≥6 and <6) the correct rate was 73.571%. Statistics result of chi-square test for the two methods had significant difference (P <0.05). The dichotomy correct rate of imaging department and neurology department were 74.92% and 69.523% respectively, which had no significant difference. The correct rate of senior employees and junior ones were 74.814% and 61.665% respectively, which had no significant difference. Conclusion The consistency and the accuracy of ASPECTS were relatively low after the initial training, which indicated that more times and strict trainings were very essential and important and Dichotomy (ASPECTS ≥6 or ASPECTS <6) had a relatively good clinical application prospection.

Key words: Ischemic stroke; Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score; Accuracy; Consistency

邓国莉，周龙江，赵义，陈斌，王礼同，彭伟，王苇. 初次培训后ASPECT评分一致性和准确性的研究[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2017, 12(12): 1104-1110.

DENG Guo-Li,ZHOU Long-Jiang, ZHAO Yi, CHEN Bin, WANG Li-Tong, PENG Wei, WANG Wei. Study on Consistency and Accuracy of ASPECTS after the Initial Training[J]. Chinese Journal of Stroke, 2017, 12(12): 1104-1110.

参考文献

[1] HACKE W，KASTE M，FIESEHI C，et al.

Intravenous thrombolysis with recombinant tissue

plasminogen activator for acute hemispheric stroke.

The European Cooperative Acute Stroke Study

（ECASS）[J]. JAMA，1995，274（13）：1017-1025.

[2] BARBER P A，DEMCHUK A M，ZHANG

J，et al. Validity and reliability of a quantitative

computed tomography score in predicting outcome

of hyperacute stroke before thrombolytic therapy.

ASPECTS Study Group. Alberta Stroke Programme

Early CT Score. Alberta Stroke Programme Early CT

Score[J]. Lancet，2000，355（9216）：1670-1674.

[3] HILL M D，DEMCHUK A M，TOMSICK T A，

et al. Using the baseline CT scan to select acute

stroke patients for IV-IA therapy[J]. AJNR Am J

Neuroradiol，2006，27（8）：1612-1616.

[4] DEMCHUK A M，HILL M D，BARBER P A，et al.

Importance of early ischemic computed tomography

changes using ASPECTS in NINDS rtPA Stroke

Study[J]. Stroke，2005，36（10）：2110-2115.

[5] DZIALOWSKI I，HILL M D，COUTTS S B，et

al. Extent of early ischemic changes on computed

tomography（CT）before thrombolysis：prognostic

value of the Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score

in ECASS Ⅱ[J]. Stroke，2006，37（4）：973-978.

[6] AVIV R I，MANDELCORN J，CHAKRABORTY

S，et al. Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Scoring

of CT perfusion in early stroke visualization and

assessment[J]. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol，2007，28

（10）：1975-1980.

[7] DEMCHUK A M，COUTTS S B. Alberta Stroke

Program Early CT Score in acute stroke triage[J].

Neuroimaging Clin N Am，2005，15（2）：409-419.

[8] LIN K，RAPALINO O，LAW M，et al. Accuracy of

the Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score during

the first 3 hours of middle cerebral artery stroke：

comparison of noncontrast CT，CT angiography

source images，and CT perfusion[J]. AJNR Am J

Neuroradiol，2008，29（5）：931-936.

[9] GUPTA A C，SCHAEFER P W，CHAUDHRY Z A，

et al. Interobserver reliability of baseline noncontrast

CT Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score for

intra-arterial stroke treatment selection[J]. AJNR

Am J Neuroradiol，2012，33（6）：1046-1049.

[10] PEXMAN J H，BARBER P A，HILL M D，et al.

Use of the Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score

（ASPECTS）for assessing CT scans in patients with

acute stroke[J]. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol，2001，22

（8）：1534-1542.

[11] GOYAL M，DEMCHUK A M，MENON B K，et

al. Randomized assessment of rapid endovascular

treatment of ischemic stroke[J]. N Engl J Med，2015，

372（11）：1019-1030.

[12] JOVIN T G，CHAMORRO A，COBO E，et al.

1110 Chin J Stroke, Dec 2017, Vol 12, No.12

Thrombectomy within 8 hours after symptom onset

in ischemic stroke[J]. N Engl J Med，2015，372（24）：

2296-2306.

[13] SAVER J L，GOYAL M，BONAFE A，et al. Stentretriever

thrombectomy after intravenous t-PA vs.

t-PA alone in stroke[J]. N Engl J Med，2015，372

（24）：2285-2295.

[14] BERKHEMER O A，FRANSEN P S，BEUMER D，

et al. A randomized trial of intraarterial treatment

for acute ischemic stroke[J]. N Engl J Med，2015，372

（1）：11-20.

[15] CASAUBON L K，BOULANGER J M，

BLACQUIERE D，et al. Canadian stroke best

practice recommendations：Hyperacute Stroke Care

Guidelines，Update 2015[J]. Int J Stroke，2015，10

（6）：924-940.

[16] POWERS W J，DERDEYN C P，BILLER J，et al.

2015 American Heart Association/American Stroke

Association focused update of the 2013 guidelines for

the early management of patients with acute ischemic

stroke regarding endovascular treatment：a guideline

for healthcare professionals from the American Heart

Association/American Stroke Association[J]. Stroke，

2015，46（10）：3020-3035.

[17] BAL S，BHATIA R，MENON B K，et al. Time

dependence of reliability of noncontrast computed

tomography in comparison to computed tomography

angiography source image in acute ischemic

stroke[J]. Int J Stroke，2015，10（1）：55-60.

[18] WARDLAW J M，VON KUMMER R，FARRALL A

J，et al. A large web-based observer reliability study

of early ischaemic signs on computed tomography.

The Acute Cerebral CT Evaluation of Stroke Study

（ACCESS）[J]. Plos One，2010，5（12）：e15757.

[19] PUETZ V，DZIALOWSKI I，HILL M D，et al. The

Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score in clinical

practice：what have we learned?[J]. Int J Stroke，

2009，4（5）：354-364.

[20] MAINALI S，WAHBA M，ELIJOVICH

L. Detection of early ischemic changes in

noncontrast CT head improved with "Stroke

Windows"[J/OL]. ISRN Neurosci，2014，2014：

654980. DOI：10.1155/2014/654980. http://doi.

org/10.1155/2014/654980.

[21] MITTAL M，SEET R，ZHANG Y，et al. Aspect

score：DWI or CT scan，which one is better marker

for stroke morbidity and outcome?[J]. Stroke，2012，

43（2）：2840.

[22] FARZIN B，FAHED R，GUILBERT F，et al. Early

CT changes in patients admitted for thrombectomy：

Intrarater and interrater agreement[J]. Neurology，

2016，87（3）：249-256.

[23] MAK H K，YAU K K，KHONG P L，et al.

Hypodensity of ＞1/3 middle cerebral artery

territory versus Alberta Stroke Programme Early

CT Score（ASPECTS）：comparison of two methods

of quantitative evaluation of early CT changes

in hyperacute ischemic stroke in the community

setting[J]. Stroke，2003，34（5）：1194-1196.

[24] COUTTS S B，HILL M D，DEMCHUK A M，

et al. ASPECTS reading requires training and

experience[J]. Stroke，2003，34（10）：e179.

[25] KIMURA K，IGUCHI Y，SHIBAZAKI K，et

al. Large ischemic lesions on diffusion-weighted

imaging done before intravenous tissue plasminogen

activator thrombolysis predicts a poor outcome in

patients with acute stroke[J]. Stroke，2008，39（8）：

2388-2391.

[26] NEZU T，KOGA M，KIMURA K，et al.

Pretreatment ASPECTS on DWI predicts 3-month

outcome following rt-PA：SAMURAI rt-PA

Registry[J]. Neurology，2010，75（6）：555-561.

[27] TURC G，APOIL M，NAGGARA O，et al. Magnetic

Resonance Imaging-DRAGON score：3-month

outcome prediction after intravenous thrombolysis

for anterior circulation stroke[J]. Stroke，2013，44

（5）：1323-1328.