›› 2010, Vol. 5 ›› Issue (04): 291-298.

• 论著 • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Evaluation of the Predominant Role in Patients with Spastic Equinus Foot after Stroke: A Clinical Study of the Effects of Block of Motor Nerve Branches to the Triceps Surae Muscle

LIU Zhi-Hua, ZHANG Hong-Cui, YU Da-Jun, et al.   

  • Received:2009-12-30 Revised:2009-11-30 Online:2010-04-20 Published:2010-04-20
  • Contact: LI Tie-Shan

胫神经小腿三头肌运动分支选择性麻醉阻滞对脑卒中痉挛性垂足责任肌筛选的研究

刘志华,张洪翠,于大君,李铁山   

  1. 山东省青岛市青岛大学医学院附属医院康复医学科
  • 通讯作者: 李铁山

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the prominent role of the triceps surae muscle through selective anestheticblocks of motor nerve branches to the triceps surae muscle on lower limb in patients with spasticequinus foot.Methods Thirty patients with stroke were assessed before and after selective anesthetic blockof the superior soleus nerve or the gastrocnemius nerve, which performed by lidocaine injection.Clinical assessments such as SR(stretch reflex), Ashworth scale, rROM(rest range of motion),AROM(active range of motion), PROM(passive range of motion), strength of plantarflexion muscle,walking speed for 10m(at cosy speed and volant speed, separately), cadence, walking distance for3mins, PCI(physical consume index), step length, toe out angle were performed 30mins beforeand after each motor block. The patients were devided into three groups, they were preoperativepostgastrocnemius,preoperative- postsoleus, postgastrocnemius – postsoleus separately. Wecompared differences in these indicators.Results Spasm index such as stretch reflex, Ashworth scale, AROM and PROM were all decreasedin postgastrocnemius, there were statistically differences compared with preoperative, (P all <0.01).Stretch reflex, Ashworth scale, rROM, AROM and PROM were all decreased in postsoleus, (P all<0.01); there were significant differences between two blocks in each of them, they showed thaton SR, AROM and PROM P all <0.01, on Ashworth, rROM P all <0.05; Plantar flexor musclestrength decreased in postgastrocnemius(P <0.01) but not in postsoleus, comparison of two blocksP <0.01; there were no significant differences on walking targets in postgastrocnemius but therewere statistically differences in postsoleus except for walking distance for 3mins compared withpreoperative, on walking speed for 10m at volant speed and cadence P all<0.01, on walking speedfor 10m at cosy speed and PCI P all<0.05.Also there were significant difference between the twoblocks except for walking distance for 3mins, they showed that on walking speed for 10m at cosyspeed P <0.05, other index P all<0.01.There were no significant difference for step length andtoe out angle in the affected side compared with preoperative, also no statistically difference wasobserved between the two blocks in the affected side.Conclusion Both soleus nerve block and gastrocnemius nerve block could alleviate spasticityin patients with spastic equinus foot, but soleus nerve block appeared more appropriate thangastrocnemius nerve block to relieve spasticity clinically, which mainly manifested in people'swalking ability. It constitutes an additional argument in favor of the predominant role of the soleusin spastic foot.

Key words: Tibial nerve; Neuromuscular blockade; Stroke; Gait disorders; neurologic

摘要: 目的 通过胫神经小腿三头肌运动神经分支选择性麻醉阻滞,确定造成脑卒中痉挛性垂足的责任肌。方法 选择30例脑卒中患者,应用2%利多卡因进行腓肠肌和比目鱼肌运动分支神经麻醉阻滞,阻滞前后对肢体痉挛指标包括牵张反射评分(stretch reflex,SR)、痉挛严重程度分级Ashworth评分、踝关节活动角度(range of motion,ROM)包括休息位ROM(rest range of motion,rROM)、主动背屈ROM(active range of motion,AROM)和被动背屈ROM(passive range of motion,PROM)、足跖屈肌肌力以及下肢步行功能状态指标如10m舒适和快速步行速度、步频、3min步行距离、能量消耗指数(physicalconsume index,PCI)以及步长和足偏角进行观察。分别比较腓肠肌阻滞前后、比目鱼肌阻滞前后,以及腓肠肌阻滞后和比目鱼肌阻滞后上述指标的变化和差异。结果 痉挛指标SR评分、Ashworth评分、AROM和PROM在腓肠肌运动分支阻滞后较阻滞前均下降,差异有统计学意义(P均<0.01);SR评分、Ashworth评分、rROM、AROM和PROM在比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞后较阻滞前均下降(P均<0.01);比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞后痉挛指标低于腓肠肌运动分支阻滞后(SR评分、AROM和PROM的P值均<0.01,Ashworth评分、rROM P值均<0.05)。对于足跖屈肌肌力,腓肠肌运动分支阻滞后较阻滞前肌力下降(P<0.01),比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞术后对肌力无影响,两种阻滞方法比较差异有统计学意义(P<0.01)。步行功能指标腓肠肌运动分支阻滞后较阻滞前无统计学差异,比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞后除3min步行距离较阻滞前无差异外,其余指标均有提高(10m快速步行速度、步频的P值均<0.01,10m舒适步行速度和PCI的P值均<0.05);除3min步行距离两种阻滞方法比较无差异外,其余指标比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞后均高于腓肠肌运动分支阻滞后(10m舒适步行速度P值<0.05,余P值均<0.01)。患侧步长和足偏角在两种阻滞方法术后较阻滞前差别均无统计学意义,两种方法比较也均无统计学差异。结论 腓肠肌运动分支和比目鱼肌运动分支利多卡因阻滞均能降低痉挛性足下垂患者的痉挛程度,但是比目鱼肌运动分支阻滞较之腓肠肌运动神经阻滞改善患者步行功能更为显著。故认为比目鱼肌是造成小腿三头肌痉挛性足下垂畸形的主要责任肌。

关键词: 胫神经; 神经肌肉阻滞; 卒中; 步态障碍; 神经性