急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎的管理相关循证指南的AGREE Ⅱ质量评价

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5765.2021.01.009

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

目的评价预防急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎相关指南的质量，为科学系统制定我国的临床指南提供参考。方法按照纳入、排除标准纳入数据库及网站检索的国内外有关预防急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎的临床指南，并按照国际公认的指南评价工具（Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation Ⅱ， AGREE Ⅱ）进行质量评价，并分析各指南推荐内容的异同。结果共纳入8篇指南，国内3篇，国外5篇。对纳入指南进行6个维度（范围和目的、参与人员、严谨性、清晰可读性、应用性、撰写的独立性）评价的平均得分分别为100%、39.58%、60.18%、36.46%、 41.67%、56.25%，2名评价者对8篇指南的评价结果Kappa值均等于0.75（均P＜0.05)，具有极好的一致性。Guidelines for the early management of patients with acute ischemic stroke及Management of patients with stroke：identification and management of dysphagia两部指南的推荐等级为A级，质量最佳；共有5篇指南推荐等级为B级；国内中文指南有1篇质量较低，推荐等级为C级；纳入的8篇指南均未单独制定出卒中相关性肺炎的最佳实践指南。结论纳入的国外指南总体质量较高，国内指南的严谨性及编辑独立性等诸多方面距离国际标准仍有一定差距，且8篇指南存在的最大问题为均未考虑患者方的意愿。现有的国内外指南均以卒中或吞咽为主，并未制定出预防急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎的指南，其针对性较低。

文章导读： 基于AGREE Ⅱ评价工具的指南评价结果可为临床急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎循证指南的制定提供科学的方法学理论依据，提高临床决策的科学性、安全性及系统性。

关键词: 卒中; 肺炎; 指南; 国际指南评价工具; 质量评价

Abstract:

Objective To evaluate the quality of acute ischemic stroke-associated pneumonia (AISAP) related guidelines, and provide a reference for developing the clinical guidelines for AISAP scientifically and systematically in China. Methods According to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, the domestic and international AISAP related guidelines searched in the database and websites were included in this study. All the guidelines were evaluated for the quality according to the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation Ⅱ (AGREE Ⅱ), and the similarities and differences among the recommendations of the guidelines were analyzed. Results A total of 8 guidelines were included, with 3 Chinese and 5 international ones. The total scores of the six dimensions (scope and purpose, participants in the development of guidelines, rigor, clarity and readability, applicability, and editorial independence) for all the guidelines were 100%, 39.58%, 60.18%, 36.46%, 41.67%, 56.25%, respectively. The Kappa values of the two evaluators for the 8 guidelines were both equal to 0.75 (both P <0.05), with excellent consistency. The class of recommendations of two guidelines was class A — Guidelines for the early management of patients with acute ischemic stroke and Management of patients with stroke: identification and management of dysphagia , with the best quality; the class of five guidelines was class B, and the class of one Chinese guideline was class C, with the worst quality. None of the included guidelines specially developed the best practice recommendations for AISAP management. Conclusions The overall quality of the foreign guidelines was relatively high, and the domestic guidelines were inferior to the foreign ones in many aspects such as the rigor and editorial independence. The biggest problem for the 8 guidelines was that they all did not consider the wishes of the patients. The current domestic and international guidelines mainly focused on stroke or swallowing, with no guideline specially for AISAP.

Key words: Stroke; Pneumonia; Guideline; Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation instrument; Quality evaluation

周鹭，刘高，和意娴，蔡恩丽. 急性缺血性卒中相关性肺炎的管理相关循证指南的AGREE Ⅱ质量评价[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2021, 16(01): 51-57.

ZHOU Lu, LIU Gao, HE Yi-Xian, CAI En-Li. Quality Evaluation of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Management of Acute Ischemic Stroke-Associated Pneumonia: A Study Based on AGREE II[J]. Chinese Journal of Stroke, 2021, 16(01): 51-57.

参考文献

[1] SMITH E E，KENT D M，BULSARA K R，et

al. Accuracy of prediction instruments for

diagnosing large vessel occlusion in individuals

with suspected stroke：a systematic review for the

2018 guidelines for the early management of patients

with acute ischemic stroke[J/OL]. Stroke，2018，49

（3）：e139[2019-01-18]. https：//doi.org/10.1161/

str.0000000000000160.

[2] SMITH E E，KENT D M，BULSARA K R，et al.

Effect of dysphagia screening strategies on clinical

outcomes after stroke：a systematic review for the

2018 guidelines for the early management of patients

with acute ischemic stroke[J/OL]. Stroke，2018，49

（3）：e123-e128[2019-01-18]. https：//doi.org/10.1161/

str.0000000000000159.

[3] HIGASHIDA R，ALBERTS M J，ALEXANDER

D N，et al. Interactions within stroke systems of

care：a policy statement from the American Heart

Association/American Stroke Association[J]. Stroke，

2013，44（10）：2961-2984.

[4] WIJDICKS E F M，SHETH K N，CARTER B S，et

al. Recommendations for the management of cerebral

and cerebellar infarction with swelling：a statement

for healthcare professionals from the American Heart

Association/American Stroke Association[J]. Stroke，

2014，45（4）：1222-1238.

[5] BROUWERS M，KHO M E，BROWMAN G P. et

al. AGREE Ⅱ：advancing guideline development，

reporting and evaluation in health care[J/OL]. CMAJ，

2010，182（18）：e839-e842[2019-01-18]. https：//doi.

org/101503/cmaj.090449.

[6] VLAYEN J，AERTGEERTS B，HANNES K，et al.

A systematic review of appraisal tools for clinical

practice guidelines：multiple similarities and one

common deficit[J]. Int J Qual Health Care，2005，17

（3）：235-242.

[7] CASAUBON L K，BOULANGER J M，GLASSER E，

et al. Canadian stroke best practice recommendations：

acute inpatient stroke care guidelines，update

2015[J]. Int J Stroke，2016，11（2）：239-252.

[8] POWERS W J，RABINSTEIN A A，ACKERSON

T，et al. 2018 Guidelines for the early management of

patients with acute ischemic stroke：a guideline for

healthcare professionals from the American Heart

Association/American Stroke Association[J/OL].

Stroke，2018，49（3）：e46-e110[2019-01-18]. https：//

doi. org/10.1161/STR.0000000000000158.

[9] GITTLER M，DAVIS A M. Guidelines for adult

stroke rehabilitation and recovery[J]. JAMA，2018，

319（8）：820-821.

[10] NETWORK S I G. Management of patients with

stroke：identification and management of dysphagia.

A national clinical guideline[EB/OL].（2010-06-29）

[2019-01-18]. https：//www.sign.ac.uk/media/1057/

sign119.pdf.

[11] 中华医学会神经病学分会. 中国急性缺血性脑卒中

诊治指南2014[J]. 中华神经科杂志，2015，48（4）：

246-257.

[12] 中华医学会神经病学分会，中华医学会神经病学分

会神经康复学组，中华医学会神经病学分会脑血管

病学组. 中国脑卒中早期康复治疗指南[J]. 中华神经

科杂志，2017，50（6）：405-412.

[13] SMITH C J，KISHORE A K，VAIL A，et

al. Diagnosis of stroke-associated pneumonia：

recommendations from the Pneumonia in Stroke

Consensus Group[J]. Stroke，2015，46（8）：2335-

2340.

[14] 中国吞咽障碍康复评估与治疗专家共识组. 中国吞

咽障碍评估与治疗专家共识[J]. 中华物理医学与康

复杂志，2018，40（1）：1-10.

[15] 郭琴，万朝敏. 临床实践指南的循证评价和应用[J].

临床儿科杂志，2011，29（3）：288-290.

[16] DANS A L，DANS L F. Appraising a tool for

guideline appraisal（the AGREE II instrument）[J]. J

Clin Epidemiol，2010，63（12）：1281-1282.

[17] AGREE Collaboration. Development and validation

of an international appraisal instrument for assessing

the quality of clinical practice guidelines：the

AGREE project [J]. Qual Saf Health Care，2003，12

（1）：18-23.