穿支动脉疾病型脑梗死进展性运动障碍的相关因素分析及预后研究

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5765.2019.11.006

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

目的分析穿支动脉疾病（penetrating artery disease，PAD）型脑梗死出现进展性运动障碍（progressive motor deficits，PMD）的相关危险因素及患者预后。方法连续入组经头颅MRI确诊的PAD型脑梗死病例，按是否出现PMD分为PMD组与非PMD组例，比较两组的人口学资料、血管危险因素、病灶特点、实验室指标、3个月和6个月预后良好（mRS评分 0～2分）率及脑梗死复发情况。进一步对PMD的可能影响因素进行多因素分析，判断其独立危险因素。结果研究共入组287例PAD型脑梗死患者，其中PMD组95例，非PMD组192例。与非PMD组相比， PMD组男性患者（P =0.03）、吸烟（P =0.04）、糖化血红蛋白（P <0.001）、Hcy（P =0.02）和D-二聚体（P =0.01）水平较高，脑梗死灶直径较大（P <0.001）。两组患者入院时NIHSS评分差异无统计学意义，但出院时PMD组NIHSS评分高于非PMD组（7.69±1.87分 vs 2.13±0.49分，P <0.001）；3个月随访PMD组预后良好率较低（55.7% vs 70.8%，P =0.01），6个月随访两组预后无显著差异；两组3个月及6个月脑梗死复发率差异无统计学意义。多因素分析显示高糖化血红蛋白水平（OR 1.083，95%CI 1.062～1.105， P =0.03）和较大的脑梗死灶直径（OR 1.051，95%CI 1.030～1.073，P =0.01）是PMD的独立危险因素。结论 PAD型脑梗死患者中，出现PMD者早期神经功能缺损较重，3个月预后较差。糖化血红蛋白水平及脑梗死灶直径可作为PAD型脑梗死患者PMD的预测指标。

文章导读： 本研究结果提示糖化血红蛋白水平较高、脑梗死灶直径大的穿支动脉疾病型脑梗死患者出现进展性运动障碍的风险更高，但出现进展性运动障碍并未影响患者的长期预后。

关键词: 穿支动脉疾病; 进展性运动障碍; 预后

Abstract:

Objective To analyze the risk factors of progressive motor dysfunction (PMD) in patients with cerebral infarction due to perforating artery disease (PAD). Methods Patients with PAD cerebral infarction diagnosed by MRI were divided into PMD group and non-PMD Group. The demographic data, vascular risk factors, lesions characteristics, laboratory test result, prognosis and stroke recurrence at 3 and 6 months were compared between the two groups. Multivariate analysis was used to determine the independent risk factors for PMD. Results A total of 287 patients with PAD were enrolled in this study, including 95 patients with PMD and 192 patients with non-PMD. The males (P =0.03), smoking (P =0.04), the glycated hemoglobin (P <0.001), homocysteine (P =0.02), D-dimer (P =0.01) and infarct diameter (P <0.001) were all significantly higher in PMD group than that in non-PMD Group. There was no significant difference in the NIHSS scores at admission between the two groups, but the NIHSS scores at discharge in PMD group was higher than that in non-PMD group (7.69±1.87 vs 2.13±0.49, P <0.001). The rate of good prognosis at 3 months in PMD group was lower than that in non-PMD Group (55.7% vs 70.8%, P =0.01), while the two groups had no statistical difference at 6 months. There were no significant difference in recurrent cerebral infarction at 3 and 6 months between the two groups. Multivariate analysis showed that high glycated hemoglobin level (OR 1.083, 95%CI 1.062-1.105, P =0.03) and large infarct diameter (OR 1.051, 95%CI 1.030-1.073, P =0.01) were independent risk factors for PMD. Conclusions Of patients with cerebral infarction due to PAD, the patients occurring PMD had more severe neurological function deficit and worse prognosis at 3 months. Glycated hemoglobin and infarct diameter can be used as predictors for PMD.

Key words: Penetrating artery disease; Progressive motor dysfunction; Prognosis

周娟, 石富铭, 陈书阁, 张丽文, 董立平, 王铁军. 穿支动脉疾病型脑梗死进展性运动障碍的相关因素分析及预后研究[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2019, 14(11): 1106-1111.

ZHOU Juan, SHI Fu-Ming, CHEN Shu-Ge, ZHANG Li-Wen, DONG Li-Ping, WANG Tie-Jun. Analysis on Factors of Progressive Motor Dysfunction and Prognosis in Patients with Cerebral Infarction due to Penetrating Artery Disease[J]. Chinese Journal of Stroke, 2019, 14(11): 1106-1111.

参考文献

[1] KNOTTNERUS I L H，TEN CATE H，LODDER

J，et al. Endothelial dysfunction in lacunar stroke：a

systematic review[J]. Cerebrovasc Dis，2009，27（5）：

519-526.

[2] DEGUCHI I，HAYASHI T，KATO Y，et al.

Treatment outcomes of tissue plasminogen activator

infusion for branch atheromatous disease[J/OL].

J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis，2013，22（5）：e168-

172. https：//doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasd

者的神经功能预后一般较好[29]。本研究发现

PMD患者3个月及6个月复发率相对较高，早

期（发病3个月）神经功能损害虽较重，但远

期（发病6个月）预后较好，与未出现病情进展

的患者预后相似。国内的氯吡格雷用于急性非

致残性缺血性脑血管病事件高危人群的疗效

（Clopidogrel in High-risk Patients With

Ac ute Non-d is abl i n g Cerebrovas c u lar

Event s，CHANCE）研究显示，早期联合使

用氯吡格雷和阿司匹林21 d可减少轻型卒中

（NIHSS评分≤3分）患者90 d内卒中复发率[30]。

而PAD型脑梗死多数症状相对较轻，属于轻

型卒中，因此CHANCE研究的结果也为PAD型

脑梗死的临床治疗和研究提供了新的思路。

虽然通过常规手段检出穿支动脉的狭窄

及硬化存在一定困难，但目前高分辨率磁共振

成像（high resolution magnetic resonance

imaging，HR-MRI）的应用使检测PAD有了可

能。HR-MRI虽然不能直接判定穿支动脉的狭

窄情况，但可以检测出穿支动脉上游载体动脉

的病变，因此可间接反映穿支动脉病变[31]。本

研究未进行HR-MRI检查以了解此类患者更详

细的病变影像学特点，随着技术的进步，针对

PAD及其所致脑梗死的后续研究中，会利用更

先进的影像学技术来进行此类患者影像学标志、

影像学与临床特点和预后关系的研究。另外，

本研究为单中心，相对样本量较小的研究，也可

能会造成一定的结果偏移，在后续研究中也会

相应调整，进行更长期、更大样本量的研究。

is.2012.10.012.

[3] JEONG H G，KIM B J，YANG M H，et al.

Neuroimaging markers for early neurologic

deterioration in single small subcortical infarction[J].

Stroke，2015，46（3）：687-691.

[4] STEINKE W，LEY S C. Lacunar stroke is the major

cause of progressive motor deficits[J]. Stroke，2002，

33（6）：1510-1516.

[5] YAMAMOTO Y，OHARA T，HAMANAKA M，et

al. Predictive factors for progressive motor deficits

in penetrating artery infarctions in two different

arterial territories[J]. J Neurol Sci，2010，288（1-2）：

170-174.

[6] JAMES F，CHERYL B，CHERYL D，et al.

Guidelines for the primary prevention of stroke：a

statement for healthcare professional[J]. Stroke，2014，

45（1）：3754-3832.

[7] INOUE T，TAMURA A，TSUTSUMI K，et al.

Acute to subacute surgical revascularization for

progressing stroke in atherosclerotic vertebrobasilar

occlusion[J]. Acta Neurochir（Wien），2012，154（8）：

1455-1461；discussion 1461.

[8] GAO S，WANG Y J，XU A D，et al. Chinese

ischemic stroke subclassification[J/OL]. Front Neurol，

2011，2：6. https：//doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2011.00006.

[9] KAPTOGE S，DI ANGELANTONIO E，LOWE

G，et al. C-reactive protein concentration and risk

of coronary heart disease，stroke，and mortality：an

individual participant meta-analysis[J]. Lancet，2010，

375（9709）：132-140.

[10] FANG Y，ZHANG S，WU B，et al. Hyperglycaemia

in acute lacunar stroke：a Chinese hospital-based

study[J]. Diab Vasc Dis Res，2013，10（3）：216-221.

[11] CHOI H Y，YANG J H，CHO H J，et al. Systemic

atherosclerosis in patients with perforating artery

territorial infarction[J]. Eur J Neurol，2010，17（6）：

788-793.

[12] YARMOHAMMADI H，CARASCA A，

YARMOHAMMADI H，et al. Patent foramen ovale

associated with the unusual presentation of unilateral

paramedian thalamic perforating artery infarction

after embolic occlusion of 'artery of percheron'：case

report and review of the literature[J]. J Neurointerv

Surg，2011，3（2）：156-159.

[13] ZHU L，HOFFMANN A，WINTERMARK M，et

al. Do microemboli reach the brain penetrating

arteries?[J]. J Surg Res，2012，176（2）：679-683.

[14] Zhang H，Prabhakar P，Sealock R，et al. Wide

genetic variation in the native pial collateral

circulation is a major determinant of variation in

severity of stroke[J]. J Cerebr Blood F Met，2010，30 （5）：923-934.

[15] WEIMAR C，MIECK T，BUCHTHAL J，et al.

Neurologic worsening during the acute phase of

ischemic stroke[J]. Arch Neurol，2005，62（3）：393-

397.

[16] ALAWNEH J A，MOUSTAFA R R，BARON J C.

Hemodynamic factors and perfusion abnormalities

in early neurological deterioration[J/OL]. Stroke，

2009，40（6）：e443-e450. https：//doi.org/10.1161/

STROKEAHA.108.532465.

[17] YAMAMOTO Y，OHARA T，HAMANAKA

M，et al. Characteristics of intracranial branch

atheromatous disease and its association with

progressive motor deficits[J]. J Neurol Sci，2011，304

（1-2）：78-82.

[18] SHAH R S，COLE J W. Smoking and stroke：the

more you smoke the more you stroke[J]. Expert Rev

Cardiovasc Ther，2010，8（7）：917-932.

[19] ALONSO N，TRAVESET A，RUBINAT E，et al.

Type 2 diabetes-associated carotid plaque burden is

increased in patients with retinopathy compared to

those without retinopathy[J]. Cardiovasc Diabetol，

2018，17（49）：1-2.

[20] KUROSAKI Y，YOSHIDA K，FUKUDA H，et al.

Asymptomatic carotid T1-high-intense plaque as a

risk factor for a subsequent cerebrovascular ischemic

event[J]. Cerebrovasc Dis，2017，43（5-6）：250-256.

[21] BAMBERG F，HETTERICH H，ROSPLESZCZ

S，et al. Subclinical disease burden as assessed

by whole-body MRI in subjects with prediabetes，

subjects with diabetes，and normal control subjects

from the general population：the KORA-MRI

study[J]. Diabetes，2017，66（1）：158-169.

[22] TZIOMALOS K，SPANOU M，BOUZIANA S

D，et al. Type 2 diabetes is associated with a worse

functional outcome of ischemic stroke[J]. World J

Diabetes，2014，5（6）：939-944.

[23] YONG M，KASTE M. Dynamic of hyperglycemia

as a predictor of stroke outcome in the ecass-Ⅱ

trial[J]. Stroke，2008，39（10）：2749-2755.

[24] NAKASE T，YOSHIOKA S，SASAKI M，et al.

Clinical evaluation of lacunar infarction and branch

atheromatous disease[J]. J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis，

2013，22（4）：406-412.

[25] KAWANO T，MIYASHITA K，TAKEUCHI M，et

al. Blood biomarkers associated with neurological

deterioration in patients with acute penetrating

artery territory infarction：a multicenter prospective

observational study[J]. Int J Stroke，2018，13（2）：

207-216.

[26] HASSAN A，HUNT B J，O'SULLIVAN M，et

al. Homocysteine is a risk factor for cerebral small

vessel disease，acting via endothelial dysfunction[J].

Brain，2004，127（1）：212-219.

[27] KRARUP L H，SANDSET E C，SANDSET P M，et

al. D-dimer levels and stroke progression in patients

with acute ischemic stroke and atrial fibrillation[J].

Acta Neurol Scand，2011，124（1）：40-44.

[28] OHARA T，YAMAMOTO Y，TAMURA A，et

al. The infarct location predicts progressive motor

deficits in patients with acute lacunar infarction in

the lenticulostriate artery territory[J]. J Neurol Sci，

2010，293（1-2）：87-91.

[29] DHARMASAROJA P A，MUENGTAWEEPONGSA

S，PATTARAARCHACHAI J. Clinical course，

prognostic factors，and long-term outcomes of

malignant middle cerebral artery infarction patients

in the modern era[J]. Neurol India，2016，64（3）：

436-441.

[30] WANG Y，WANG Y，ZHAO X，et al. Clopidogrel

with aspirin in acute minor stroke or transient

ischemic attack[J]. N Engl J Med，2013，369（1）：

11-19.

[31] XU W H. Large artery：an important target for

cerebral small vessel diseases[J]. Ann Transl Med，

2014，2（8）：78.