BPAS-MRI在椎-基底动脉颅内段夹层鉴别诊断中的应用

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5765.2017.04.006

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

目的探讨一种新型的磁共振血管成像技术——椎-基底动脉平行解剖磁共振成像（basi -parallel anatomic scanning，BPAS）联合磁共振血管成像（magnetic resonance angiography，MRA）对椎-基底动脉颅内段夹层鉴别诊断的作用。方法参照文献BPAS的扫描条件，由西安交通大学第二附属医院影像科医师及技师探寻适合3.0- MR的扫描及图像处理参数，回顾性分析神经内科部分住院及门诊MRA显示为椎-基底动脉颅内段纤细或不显影、同期进行了BPAS检查的142例患者，其中临床疑诊为动脉夹层者20例，动脉硬化者60例，先天发育不良者62例，由两位未知患者临床资料的影像医师分别对所有患者的MRA及BPAS影像进行阅片，对20例临床疑诊夹层的病例MRA及MRA+BPAS影像诊断结果进行ROC曲线分析，并对两位影像医师的诊断结果进行一致性评估。结果两位影像医师对20例夹层患者MRA+BPAS及MRA阅片诊断结果的ROC曲线下面积分别为0.93 vs 0.70和0.96 vs 0.75（P＜0.01），提示MRA联合BPAS比单纯MRA的ROC曲线下面积明显增加；MRA 联合BPAS诊断椎-基底动脉颅内段夹层的灵敏度比单纯MRA高（100% vs 55%，100% vs 60%，P ＜0.01）；而两种诊断方法的特异度无显著差异（86.89% vs 85.25%，P =0.85；92.62% vs 90.16%， P =0.65）；两位影像医师对椎-基底动脉颅内段夹层的诊断结果具有高度的一致性（Kappa=0.85）。结论 BPAS检查可通过显示血管外径与MRA联合精确评估椎-基底动脉颅内段血管状况，区分该部位血管病变为夹层、动脉硬化或先天性发育不良，为该部位血管病变临床治疗方案提供依据。

文章导读： BPAS可提供椎-基底动脉颅内段血管外径信息，属无创、简便的检查方法，联合MRA对该部位病变的诊断及鉴别诊断具有重要价值。

关键词: BPAS-MRI; 椎-基底动脉颅内段; 动脉夹层; 鉴别诊断

Abstract:

Objective To explore the effect of combining a new MRI technique named basi-parallel anatomic scanning (BPAS)-magnetic resonance (MR) imaging with time-of-flight (TOF)-MR angiography (MRA) in the diagnosis of differentiating intracranial vertebrobasilar artery dissection (VBD). Methods Radiologists and radiographer in the Second Affiliated Hospital, School of Medicine, Xi'an Jiaotong University explored and acquired BPAS scanning parameters suitable for 3.0-MR scanning and image processing according to the screening criteria in the reference of BPAS. A total of 142 patients who underwent BPAS-MR imaging and 3D TOF-MRA in inpatient and outpatient neurology department, including clinical suspected diagnosis of 20 cases of VBD, 60 cases of atherosclerotic narrowing, and 62 cases of hypoplastic arteries, were retrospectively analyzed. MRA and BPAS images were analyzed by two readers blinded to the patients’ clinical data. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves were performed to compare the capability of conventional

MRA with and without BPAS imaging in suspected VBD cases. The consistency of diagnosis results of 2 observers were also evaluated. Results The area under the curve was increased significantly by combining BPAS imaging findings with MRA (0.93 vs 0.70, 0.96 vs 0.75, P <0.01, respectively by reader No.1 and No.2). In addition, the sensitivity was 100% for both readers and significantly greater than MRA (55%, 60% for both readers, P <0.01). However, specificities were not significantly different (86.89% vs 85.25%, P =0.85; 92.62% vs 90.16%, P =0.65). The consistency of diagnosis results of 2 observers was excellent (Kappa=0.85). Conclusion Combining BPAS and MRA can accurately evaluate the intracranial vertebrobasilar condition through revealing the surface appearance of artery, and differentiate VBD from atherosclerosis or hypoplasia, and provide evidence for corresponding treatments.

Key words: BPAS-MRI; Vertebrobasilar intracranial artery; Artery dissection; Differential diagnosis

张桂莲，马珠琳，李晓会，张秋娟，陈敬菊，滕国良，刘娇，李涛，王何莹，朱新业. BPAS-MRI在椎-基底动脉颅内段夹层鉴别诊断中的应用[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2017, 12(04): 320-326.

ZHANG Gui-Lian, MA Zhu-Lin, LI Xiao-Hui, et al.. The Application of Intracranial Vertebrobasilar Artery Dissection Differential Diagnosis with BPAS-MRI[J]. Chinese Journal of Stroke, 2017, 12(04): 320-326.

参考文献

1 Han M，Rim NJ，Lee JS，et al. Feasibility of

high-resolution MR imaging for the diagnosis of

intracranial vertebrobasilar artery dissection[J]. Eur

Radiol，2014，24：3017-3024.

2 Naganawa S，Ito T，Shimada H，et al. Cerebral black

blood MR angiography with the interleaved multi-slab

three-dimensional fast spin echo sequence[J]. Radiat

Med，1997，15：385-388.

3 Nagahata M，Hosoya T，Adachi M，et al. Basi-parallel

anatomical scanning (BPAS) MRI：a simple MRI

technique for demonstrating the surface appearance of

the intracranial vertebrobasilar artery[J]. Nihon Igaku

Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi，2003，63：582-584.

4 Katada K. MR imaging of brain surface structures：

surface anatomy scanning (SAS)[J]. Neuroradiology，

1990，32：439-448.

5 Nagahata M，Abe Y，Ono S，et al. Surface appearance

of the vertebrobasilar artery revealed on basiparallel

anatomic scanning (BPAS)-MR imaging：its role for

brain MR examination[J]. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol，

2005，26：2508-2513.

6 Gottesman RF，Sharma P，Robinson KA，et al.

Imaging characteristics of symptomatic vertebral

artery dissection：a systematic review[J]. Neurologist，

2012，18：255-260.

7 Rodal lec MH，Ma r t e au V，Ge r b e r S，e t a l .

Craniocervical arterial dissection：spectrum of

imaging f indings and differential diagnosis[J].

Radiographics，2008，28：1711-1728.

8 Arnold M，Bousser MG，Fahrni G，et al. Vertebral

artery dissection：presenting findings and predictors

of outcome[J]. Stroke，2006，37：2499-2503.

9 马冠生，孔灵芝，栾德春，等. 中国居民吸烟行为的现

状分析[J]. 中国慢性病预防与控制，2005，13：195-199.

10 Casolla B，Dequatre-Ponchelle N，Rossi C，et al.

Heavy alcohol intake and intracerebral hemorrhage：

characteristics and effect on outcome[J]. Neurology，

2012，79：1109-1115.

11 Park JH，Kim JM，Roh JK. Hypoplastic vertebral

artery：frequency and associations with ischemic

stroke territory[J]. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry，

2007，78：954-958.

12 王建华，刘民. 流行病学[M]. 北京：人民卫生出版社，

2008.

13 Nagahata M，Manabe H，Hasegawa S，et al. Basiparallel

anatomical scanning (BPAS) -MRI：a

simple and useful MRI technique for pre-procedural

evaluation in cases of basilar artery occlusion[J].

Interv Neuroradiol，2004，10：105-107.

14 Yamamoto J，Sakai N，Yokoyama T. Basi-parallel

anatomical scanning magnetic resonance imaging

in patients with bilateral vertebrobasilar artery

dissections[J]. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo)，2011，51：

575-578.

15 Yoshida M，Ezura M，Mino M. Acute occlusion and

recanalization of vertebral artery dissection after

subarachnoid hemorrhage：usefulness of bilateral

simultaneous vertebral angiography and basiparallel

anatomic scanning-magnetic resonance imaging. Case

report[J]. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo)，2012，52：87-90.

16 Itabashi R，Mori E，Furui E，et al. A dilated surface

appearance on basiparallel anatomic scanningmagnetic

resonance imaging is a useful tool for the

diagnosis of spontaneous vertebral artery dissection in

lateral medullary infarction[J]. J Stroke Cerebrovasc

Dis，2014，23：805-810.

17 Katsuno M，Kobayashi S. Diagnosis of vertebral

ar tery dissection with basiparallel anatomical

scanning magnetic resonance imaging[J]. J Nippon

Med Sch，2011，78：367-373.

18 Na g a h a t a M，Manabe H，Hasegawa S，e t a l .

Morphological change of unruptured vertebral artery

dissection on serial MR examinations. Evaluation of

the arterial outer contour by basi-parallel anatomical

scanning (BPAS)-MRI[J]. Interv Neuroradiol，2006，

12：133-136.

19 Takada H，Hyogo T，Kataoka T，et al. Diagnosis of

vertebral artery dissection by basi-parallel anatomical

scanning (BPAS) MRI[J]. Interv Neuroradiol，2006，

12：129-132.

20 Iwata R，Yamashita K，Nishikawa T，et al. Diagnosis

of anterior inferior cerebellar artery occlusion on

magnetic resonance angiography with reference to

basiparallel anatomic scanning-magnetic resonance

imaging[J]. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo)，2010，50：987-

989.

21 Shin JH，Suh DC，Choi CG，et al. Vertebral artery

dissection：spectrum of imaging f indings with

emphasis on angiography and correlation with clinical

presentation[J]. Radiographics，2000，20：1687-1696.

22 Leclerc X，Lucas C，Godefroy O，et al. Preliminary

experience using contrast-enhanced MR angiography

to assess vertebral artery structure for the follow-up

of suspected dissection[J]. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol，

1999，20：1482-1490.

23 Fatima Z，Motosugi U，Okumura A，et al. Basiparallel

anatomical scanning (BPAS)-MRI can

improve discrimination of vertebral artery dissection

from atherosclerosis and hypoplasia[J]. Acad Radiol，

2012，19：1362-1367.

24 Astor BC，Sharrett AR，Coresh J，et al. Remodeling

of carotid ar teries detected with MR imaging：

atherosclerosis risk in communities carotid MRI

study[J]. Radiology，2010，256：879-886.

25 Steinke W，Els T，Hennerici M. Compensatory

carotid artery dilatation in early atherosclerosis[J].

Circulation，1994，89：2578-2581.

26 Zhou M，Zheng H，Gong S，et al. Vertebral artery

hypoplasia and ver tebral a r tery dissect ion：a

hospital-based cohort study[J]. Neurology，2015，84：

818-824.

of the vertebrobasilar artery revealed on basiparallel

anatomic scanning (BPAS)-MR imaging：its role for

brain MR examination[J]. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol，

2005，26：2508-2513.

6 Gottesman RF，Sharma P，Robinson KA，et al.

Imaging characteristics of symptomatic vertebral

artery dissection：a systematic review[J]. Neurologist，

2012，18：255-260.

7 Rodal lec MH，Ma r t e au V，Ge r b e r S，e t a l .

Craniocervical arterial dissection：spectrum of

imaging f indings and differential diagnosis[J].

Radiographics，2008，28：1711-1728.

8 Arnold M，Bousser MG，Fahrni G，et al. Vertebral

artery dissection：presenting findings and predictors

of outcome[J]. Stroke，2006，37：2499-2503.

9 马冠生，孔灵芝，栾德春，等. 中国居民吸烟行为的现

状分析[J]. 中国慢性病预防与控制，2005，13：195-199.

10 Casolla B，Dequatre-Ponchelle N，Rossi C，et al.

Heavy alcohol intake and intracerebral hemorrhage：

characteristics and effect on outcome[J]. Neurology，

2012，79：1109-1115.

11 Park JH，Kim JM，Roh JK. Hypoplastic vertebral

artery：frequency and associations with ischemic

stroke territory[J]. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry，

2007，78：954-958.

12 王建华，刘民. 流行病学[M]. 北京：人民卫生出版社，

2008.

13 Nagahata M，Manabe H，Hasegawa S，et al. Basiparallel

anatomical scanning (BPAS) -MRI：a

simple and useful MRI technique for pre-procedural

evaluation in cases of basilar artery occlusion[J].

Interv Neuroradiol，2004，10：105-107.

14 Yamamoto J，Sakai N，Yokoyama T. Basi-parallel

anatomical scanning magnetic resonance imaging

in patients with bilateral vertebrobasilar artery

dissections[J]. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo)，2011，51：

575-578.

15 Yoshida M，Ezura M，Mino M. Acute occlusion and

recanalization of vertebral artery dissection after

subarachnoid hemorrhage：usefulness of bilateral

simultaneous vertebral angiography and basiparallel

anatomic scanning-magnetic resonance imaging. Case

report[J]. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo)，2012，52：87-90.

16 Itabashi R，Mori E，Furui E，et al. A dilated surface

appearance on basiparallel anatomic scanningmagnetic

resonance imaging is a useful tool for the

diagnosis of spontaneous vertebral artery dissection in

[1]	张一歌, 张婉, 张璐阳, 王鑫, 丁澜, 王玉莹, 裴璐璐, 方慧, 许予明, 宋波. 责任动脉闭塞与夹层相关缺血性卒中复发的相关性分析[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2022, 17(09): 932-936.
[2]	仲伟斌, 王鹏飞, 于进超, 张金彪, 李振光. 支架治疗颈动脉夹层导致急性脑梗死2例报告及文献复习[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2022, 17(06): 653-657.
[3]	陈媚娇, 金海娣, 刘恺鸣. 缘于颈动脉夹层的头痛特征[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2022, 17(05): 477-482.
[4]	毕京凤, 李琳琳, 刘欣瑶, 张英魁. 颈部动脉夹层磁共振成像多序列评估与信号解读[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2022, 17(04): 402-406.
[5]	杨卜凡, 邹新宇, 龚小沉, 都泓材, 陈忠伦, 唐宇凤, 李肇坤. 反应性红细胞增多症伴大脑前动脉夹层动脉瘤致脑梗死1例[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2022, 17(03): 310-313.
[6]	边祥兵，林家骥，张森皓，董小楠，刘铁芳，段曹辉，娄昕，吕晋浩. 颅内椎-基底动脉夹层形态学与后循环缺血程度的相关性研究[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2021, 16(05): 440-445.
[7]	鲁明，陆菁菁，樊青. 新型口服抗凝剂达比加群酯治疗椎动脉夹层1例[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2021, 16(04): 398-401.
[8]	胡明，贺雄军，张亮，黎杰，刘亚杰. 脑动脉夹层的诊断及治疗[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2020, 15(10): 1044-1047.
[9]	张亮，贺雄军，黎凯锋，黎杰，胡明，刘亚杰. 动脉夹层所致急性前循环大血管闭塞性卒中血管内治疗疗效分析[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2020, 15(10): 1053-1057.
[10]	周宏星，黎凯锋，黄静，黎杰，张亮，贺雄军，刘亚杰. 复发性椎动脉夹层1例并文献回顾[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2020, 15(10): 1058-1061.
[11]	霍康，谭颖，颜雪珍，镇磊，荐志洁，鱼丽萍，陈晨. 同型半胱氨酸代谢基因突变的致死性青年椎动脉夹层1例[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2020, 15(10): 1062-1066.
[12]	黎杰，贺雄军，黎凯锋，胡明，张亮，周宏星，王泽群，王一凡，刘亚杰. 颅内动脉夹层的发病机制、影像学特点和自然病程[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2020, 15(10): 1067-1072.
[13]	张熙，苏俊辉，靳令经，滕飞. 脑梗死与脑出血早期鉴别的血清标志物概述[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2019, 14(04): 389-394.
[14]	蔺雪梅, 宋金鑫, 高逸飞, 王芳, 段康丽, 时宏, 吴松笛. 颈内动脉夹层后视力下降1例[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2018, 13(06): 616-621.
[15]	房亚兰, 常俊森, 牛小媛. 颈动脉夹层影像学特点及预后分析[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2018, 13(03): 232-236.