药物临床试验方法学进展与质量管理规范教学新模式初步研究

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1673-5765.2017.09.026

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

目的探讨完善药物临床试验质量管理规范（good clinical practice，GCP）指南及改进传统GCP教学方法。方法采用定性研究的方法，形成GCP关键绩效指标（key performance indicators，KPI）。针对KPI采用线上和线下教学相结合的模式。并在药物临床试验监察过程中，对KPI的遵循进行持续质量改进。研究实用临床试验（pragmatic clinical trials，PCT）规律，形成新方法的GCP要求，并和国际指南相比较。结果应用定性研究的方法得到的GCP指南的KPI，具有代表性和可操作性，有利于GCP指南的掌握和遵循。针对KPI指标的持续质量改进项目，有利于药物临床试验质量提高。结论通过关键绩效指标的设立和持续质量改进等GCP教学新模式，可提高药物临床试验的质量。

关键词: 临床试验; 质量管理规范; 绩效指标; 质量改进; 教学

Abstract:

Objective To investigate how to improve good clinical practice (GCP) Guideline in clinical trials and traditional teaching methods. Methods Key Performance Indicators (KPI) for GCP was established by the qualitative method. Online teaching and offline teaching of KPI were used. Continuous quality improvement was carried by complying with the KPI during the monitoring and inspection of clinical trials. GCP rules for pragmatic clinical trial (PCT) were set up and compared with the international regulations. Results KPI for GCP based on the qualitative research was representative and operable, which can help to understand and comply with the GCP guideline. Continuous quality improvement through KPI could be helpful for quality improvement of drug clinical trial. Conclusion The quality of drug clinical trial can be improved by the new teaching method of GCP of establishing the KPIs and continuous quality improvement.

Key words: Clinical trials; Good Clinical Practice; Performance indicators; Quality improvement; Teaching

郑华光，王伊龙，李姝雅，赵性泉，王春雪，王拥军. 药物临床试验方法学进展与质量管理规范教学新模式初步研究[J]. 中国卒中杂志, 2017, 12(09): 877-880.

ZHENG Hua-Guang, WANG Yi-Long, LI Shu-Ya, ZHAO Xing-Quan, WANG Chun-Xue, WANG Yong-Jun. Progress of Drug Clinical Trial Methodology and Pilot Study on New Model of Good Clinical Practice Teaching[J]. Chinese Journal of Stroke, 2017, 12(09): 877-880.

参考文献

[1] GRIMES D A，HUBACHER D，NANDA K，et

al. The good clinical practice guideline：a bronze

standard for clinical research[J]. Lancet，2005，366

（9480）：172-174.

[2] MENTZ R J，HERNANDEZ A F，BERDAN L G，et

al. Good clinical practice guidance and pragmatic

clinical trials：Balancing the best of both worlds[J].

circulation，2016，133（9）：872-880.

[3] ANTMAN E M，BIERER B E. Standards for

Clinical research：Keeping pace with the technology

of the future[J]. Circulation，2016，133（9）：823-

582.

[4] DALY J，WILLIS K，SMALL R，et al. A hierarchy

of evidence for assessing qualitative health

research[J]. J Clin Epidemiol，2007，60（1）：43-49.

[5] SHAWAR Y R，SHIFFMAN J，SPIEGEL D A.

Generation of political priority for global surgery：a

qualitative policy analysis[J]. Lancet Glob Health，

2015，3（8）：e487-495.

[6] PATERSON Q S，THOMA B，MILNE W K，et

al. A systematic review and qualitative analysis to

determine quality indicators for health professions

education blogs and podcasts[J]. J Grad Med Educ，

2015，7（4）：549-554.

[7] LIN M，THOMA B，TRUEGER NS，et al.

Quality indicators for blogs and podcasts used in

medical education：modified Delphi consensus

recommendations by an international cohort of

health professions educators[J]. Postgrad Med J，

2015，91（1080）：546-550.

[8] HANNA M，MINGA A，FAO P，et al. Development

of a checklist of quality indicators for clinical trials

in resource-limited countries：the French National

Agency for Research on AIDS and Viral Hepatitis

（ANRS） experience[J]. Clin Trials，2013，10（2）：

300-318.

[9] HENLEY P，ELANGO V，HORSTICK O，et al.

Development of the good health research practice

course：ensuring quality across all health research in

humans[J]. Health Res Policy Syst，2017，15（1）：28.

[10] XIAN Y，WU J，O'BRIEN E C，et al. Real world

effectiveness of warfarin among ischemic stroke

patients with atrial fibrillation：observational

analysis from Patient-Centered Research into

Outcomes Stroke Patients Prefer and Effectiveness

Research（PROSPER）study[J]. BMJ，2015，351：

h3786. DOI：10. 1136/bmj. h3786.

[11] FORD I，NORRIE J. Pragmatic Trials[J]. N Engl J

Med，2016，375（5）：454-463.

[12] ANDERSON CS，ARIMA H，LAVADOS P.

Cluster-randomized，crossover trial of head

positioning in acute stroke[J]. N Engl J Med，2017，

376（25）：2437-2447.

[13] DREGAN A，VAN STAA T P，，MCDERMOTT

L，et al. Point-of-care cluster randomized trial in

stroke secondary prevention using electronic health

records[J]. Stroke，2014，45（7）：2066-2071.

[14] SATHER MR，RAISCH DW，HAAKENSON

CM，et al. Promoting good clinical practices in

the conduct of clinical trials：experiences in the

Department of Veterans Affairs Cooperative Studies

Program[J]. Control Clin Trials，2003，24（5）：570-

584.

[15] KUUSISTO H，VIRKKI M，WUOLIJOKI E，et

al. Hospital training program increases awareness

of Good Clinical Practice（GCP）[J]. Contemp Clin

Trials，2011，32（3）：339-341.

[16] MCGRAW D，GREENE SM，MINER CS，et al.

Privacy and confidentiality in pragmatic clinical

trials[J]. Clin Trials，2015，12（5）：520-529.

[17] MCKINNEY RE JR，BESKOW LM，FORD DE，et

al. Use of altered informed consent in pragmatic

clinical research[J]. Clin Trials，2015，12（5）：494-

502.